What Is the Highest IQ Possible? The Answer Breaks the Scale

A blue jigsaw puzzle with a missing piece, picturing the search for the highest IQ possible

So what is the highest IQ possible?

It is a fair question. It also has a strange answer.

There is no measured highest score. Not really.

The tests used today stop telling the truth near 160. Above that point, the numbers are guesses drawn from a curve, not scores earned on a test.

And the most famous big number of all, 228, came from a different kind of maths entirely. A kind no test uses any more.

So here is the short answer, up front. The scale does not have a top. It has a breaking point.

The rest of this post shows you where it breaks, and why.

1) The famous 228 came from a child’s test

The number everyone quotes belongs to Marilyn vos Savant.

In September 1956, when she was ten years old, she took a children’s test, the 1937 Stanford-Binet. The test put her mental age at 22 years and 10 months. Her real age was ten.

The old formula did the rest. Mental age divided by real age, times 100. That gives 228.

Guinness printed the number. She was listed in the Guinness Book of World Records under “Highest IQ” from 1986 to 1989, and she entered its Hall of Fame in 1988.

Then, in 1990, Guinness retired the category. The book said IQ tests were too unreliable to crown one record holder.

No one has held the title since. There is no title to hold.

So the 228 is real arithmetic. It is just arithmetic on a formula that no modern test uses. It is not a score on the scale used today, and it was never meant to sit beside one.

2) The old formula counted ages, not people

The ratio formula was simple. Take the age a child’s mind works at. Divide it by the child’s real age. Multiply by 100.

Lewis Terman set the formula out in 1916, and for a while it worked well enough. A ten-year-old who thought like a twelve-year-old scored 120. Neat. Easy to explain.

See also  What Is a Good IQ Score? 5 Numbers You Need to Know

But the formula had a flaw that grew with age. Mental age stops rising in the late teens. Real age keeps going.

A bright ten-year-old could score 200 on paper. A bright adult with the same sharp mind would score far lower, because the top of the mental age scale had already been reached.

The same mind, measured at two ages, gave two wildly different numbers.

That is not a measure. That is a trick of the maths.

Test makers saw the flaw and dropped the formula. The 1960 edition of that test switched to a new way of scoring. The ratio was gone.

3) The modern score counts people your age

The new way is called deviation IQ, and it is the scale every modern test uses.

It does not divide ages at all. It places you beside people your own age, on a bell curve with an average of 100.

One step on the curve is 15 points. That step is called a standard deviation.

Score 130 and you sit two steps above the middle. That is about 2 people in every 100.

Score 145 and you sit three steps above the middle. That is about 1 person in 740.

Score 160 and you sit four steps above the middle. That is about 1 person in 30,000.

Notice what has changed. The question is no longer “how old is this mind?” It is “how rare is this result among people the same age?”

That is a fairer question. It is also a question with a built-in limit. And the limit is the point of this post.

4) The test runs out of hard questions

A test can only separate people if it has questions hard enough to trip them up.

Think of a spelling test with ten easy words. Two sharp spellers both get ten out of ten. The test cannot say which one is sharper. It ran out of hard words.

See also  Learn IQ: What It Means & 15 Proven Ways to Improve It

IQ tests hit the same wall. It is called a ceiling effect.

A very bright person answers nearly every question right. So does the next very bright person. The test sees two near-perfect papers and has no way to rank them.

Adding harder questions helps only a little. Each new question must be tried out on real people first, to learn how hard it really is. And at the far top of the scale, there are very few real people to try it on.

So the test tops out. The major tests used today report full-scale scores from about 40 to 160, and then they stop.

They stop at 160 not because the human mind stops there. They stop because the tool stops working there.

5) The norm group is far too small

There is a second limit, and it is even simpler.

To set a score, test makers first give the test to a sample group. They watch how that group scores, then they build the scale from the results. That group is called the norm group.

For the big tests, the norm group holds about 2,200 people.

Now do the maths. A score of 160 means about 1 person in 30,000. A group of 2,200 people would be expected to hold none.

So the top of the table is not built from real people at that level. It is drawn by stretching the curve beyond the people who were actually tested.

That stretching is called extrapolation. It is a fair guess, made with good maths. But a guess is not a measurement.

Some editions offer extended scoring above 160 for gifted children. That reaches higher the same way, by stretching the curve further. Present those numbers for what they are: a stretch of the line, not a score earned on the test.

This is why the field treats reports far above 160 with suspicion. The further a number sits from the middle, the less the tool behind it can be trusted.

See also  Hard Riddles: 25 Brain Busters Almost No One Solves Alone

What the big numbers do not show

Here is the caveat, because every honest post needs one.

Online tests are not bound by any norm group. Some of them print 180, 190, even 200. A number printed without a named test, a scale and a date is not a test result. It is a screen decoration.

Nor does any body today keep a record for the highest IQ. Guinness gave that up in 1990, and no one has taken it over. The title does not exist.

And a high score, even a real one, is still only a rank on one kind of task, taken on one day. It says nothing about how a person thinks in a crisis, or how kind they are, or what they build with the mind they have.

The scale measures a narrow slice of thinking. It was never a measure of a whole person.

Wrapping up: the scale ends before the mind does

The highest IQ possible has no clean answer, because the question itself is built on a mistake.

It assumes the scale runs all the way up, like a ladder with no last rung. It does not. It runs to about 160, and then the rungs give out.

The famous 228 belongs to an old formula that counted ages, not people. The modern scale counts people, and it runs out of hard questions and real people at the top.

None of that makes the mind smaller. It makes the tool honest.

A ruler that ends at 30 centimetres does not mean nothing is taller. It means you need a different way to measure tall things.

So the next time a huge number flashes past, ask one plain question. Measured how, on what scale, against whom?

If no one can answer that, the number is a story, not a score.